(Photo from Tipster Hog)
I’ve been hearing more and more experts who are sharing a high regard for Jess Todd, so let’s take a closer look at him.
Background
Todd transferred from Navarro College to Arkansas after obliterating NJCAA hitters for two seasons. He handled the notoriously tough SEC almost as effortlessly as he handled JUCO hitters, striking out 128 in 93.1 innings with a 2.89 ERA. He earned national player of the week honors after he set an Arkansas and SEC Tournament record with 17 K’s in 8 IP on May 24. He utterly dominated in the month of May in particular, fanning 49 in 31.1 innings with a 0.57 ERA. The rotation of Nick Schmidt (1st round, 23rd overall by San Diego), Duke Welker (2nd round, 68th overall by Pittsburgh) and Todd (2nd round, 82nd overall) made for a pretty formidable three-pronged attack for the Hogs. Todd statistically was the best of all three, working at first out of the bullpen and later cementing a spot in the rotation. His signed 7/20/07 for a $400K bonus. I’m guessing Todd was taken after his rotation mates because he projects more as a reliever while Schmidt and Welker are more projectable. Fun fact: He is a former high school teammate of fellow Cardinal farmhand Josh Wilson.
Scouting
Todd’s stuff is also rated the best of all his Razorback rotation mates. He primarily works with a 90-94 mph four-seamer, and a hard mid-80s slider that’s a put away pitch. Baseball America noted that both pitches were some of the best in the Cardinal draft. He also throws an upper-80s two-seamer and a circle change that moves like a splitter. Both rate as fringe average or below. His velocity was down a little bit towards the end of the season due to fatigue, but that didn’t make him less dominating in the New York Penn. A lot of people feel his ticket to the big leagues is in relief, because he throws with some effort, and he’s a bit “smallish” for a starter, standing at 5’11”. Carlos Gomez said:

Todd has an aggressive “stepover” that kickstarts his explosive hip rotation into footplant. Todd is a pitcher who just “comes at you.” As I said with (Tim) Alderson, guys with aggressive lower body action tend to be more effective with offspeed pitches because hitters will try to “hit the motion” instead of letting the ball travel. You’ll probably see Todd strike out many hitters who will jump at his filthy slider. I like his aggressiveness and expect him to move pretty quickly. Stick him in the bullpen, let him go all out, and watch him be a better version of the “slider happy” Turk Wendell.
Performance
Lots to like here. Todd struck out 197 batters in 151.2 innings pitched. His walk rate is low, he keeps the ball on the ground and in the park. Because he’s a “slider happy” RHP, his platoon splits are sorta noticeable. Southpaw batters hit .284/.330/.330 against him, whereas right handers hit .178/.230/.263. In college, lefties were .269/.331/.381 against; righties .217/.287/.266. He also walked lefties more at least in college– 3.38 BB/9 against 2.42. Professionally, it was less of an issue–2.61 versus 2.27.
Outlook
I like Todd a lot. He was a favorite pick of mine on draft day, and he hit the ground running in his pro debut. He could jump to Palm Beach to start the season after a very strong showing in the instructional leagues this past fall; he allowed one earned run on a hit while striking out 15 there and walking none. His velocity also returned. The consensus view of his long-term outlook is in the bullpen, but I think he should get every opportunity to start. I see him possibly taking the Brad Thompson path to the big leagues—starting until reaching AAA and then converting to relief. Like Wonderbrad, Todd should have no major troubles in the lower minors. I like his future better because of the strong K rates, and I see him setting up in a couple of years.
Filed under: Jess Todd, prospect profiles














The circle change that acts like a splitter sounds very intriging. If he could fashion that into an above average pitch that would be something to see.
as long as his elbow holds up to all those sliders we should at least get a solid set-up man out of todd, and if he can improve that change he just might stick in the rotation. the thing i like about him is that he has plus stuff and great control. with a lot of recent cardinals picks it seemed like they had stuff, but not much control (lambert, ottavino, perez, daley).
is it just me, or does todd seem a lot like huston street? both are smaller righties that get by on their sliders, but also have pretty good fastballs and very good control.
Jess and Wilson weren’t actually high school teammates. Jess went to Kilgore and Wilson went to Whitehouse. The two towns are only 30 minutes apart and are in the same district. However, I know Jess and Wilson were friends and I am sure they were on the same team at one time or another.
FGC-
You know, I hadn’t really thought about a comp to Street, but now that you say something, I think I like it. They do seem to have a lot in common; their musculature even seems similar. I wonder if Todd’s fastball has the same kind of run to it? I’ve heard about his velocity, but I haven’t seen any word on his natural movement. Good call. Let’s hope Todd moves at a similar pace but avoids the injury bug.
If I were the Cardinals, I think I would make developing his changeup a top priority. Personally, I would still keep him in the pen, but I think adding in an average or better change to the package he already possesses would make him damn near untouchable. A stronger change would also go a long way toward helping to preserve his arm; if he doesn’t come up with another lower stress option, I think his durability could be a question mark in the not so distant future. Also, I would like to see him finish with his body and arm further down. I really like his delivery overall, but he looks a little upright at the finish. I’m a stickler on pitcher follow throughs, though. It’s just one of those things for me. I haven’t seen any other angles on his delivery, also, so I may be seeing something that isn’t there. You’ve got to love that stepover, though. Really solid. So far, he’s looking like one monster of a good draft pick.
rb, if you watch his draft video on mlb.com they have a side view of his delivery.
Any word on Josh Wilson and if his arm humptied back together after about two and a half years of trouble? I sure hope so, he is one of quite a few players we have now who have the potential this system lacked just a few years ago…
Noticed no one mentioned his character and being teachable. I watched him all through High School, and he was always calm and cool headed. He was very likeable because of his good character and personality. I pray for a good future for him as he is so deserving.
i used to be on his baseball team in little league in kilgore. pretty cool